Judge says $30bn not enough for Visa and Mastercard settlement

A federal judge in Brooklyn has rejected a proposed $30 billion settlement between Visa and Mastercard and millions of merchants, stating that the card giants could likely withstand a "substantially greater" payout.

The decision, announced by US District Judge Margo Brodie, deals a significant blow to efforts to resolve a long-running antitrust dispute over swipe fees.

In her 88-page opinion, Judge Brodie criticised the estimated $6 billion in annual savings for merchants as "paltry" compared to the approximately $100 billion in fees paid to accept Visa and Mastercard transactions in 2023. The judge noted that while she couldn't determine with certainty the card companies' ability to withstand a larger judgement without evidence of their profitability, "the evidence strongly suggests that they could".

The proposed settlement, which would have covered more than 12 million merchants, aimed to lower and cap interchange fees—the charges retailers pay for processing card transactions. Under the terms, the typical 1.5 per cent to 3.5 per cent swipe fee would have been reduced by 0.04 percentage points for three years, with fees capped for five years.

However, Judge Brodie found these changes inadequate, stating they fell short of the "best possible" recovery for merchants. She argued that the settlement would have kept fees significantly above competitive levels and maintained the controversial "Honour All Cards" rule, which requires merchants to accept all cards from a network or none at all.

Both Visa and Mastercard expressed disappointment with the decision. Visa stated its belief that "direct resolution with merchants is the best way forward", while Mastercard emphasised that the settlement would have encouraged competition and provided certainty for millions of businesses.

The antitrust litigation, which began in 2005, may now proceed to trial unless a new settlement is reached. The case has garnered significant attention from the retail industry, with many merchants and trade groups, including the National Retail Federation, objecting to the proposed settlement terms.

As the legal battle continues, the outcome could have far-reaching implications for the payments industry and the costs borne by retailers and, ultimately, consumers.



Share Story:

Recent Stories


Data trust in the AI era: Building customer confidence through responsible banking
In the second episode of FStech’s three-part video podcast series sponsored by HCLTech, Sudip Lahiri, Executive Vice President & Head of Financial Services for Europe & UKI at HCLTech examines the critical relationship between data trust, transparency, and responsible AI implementation in financial services.

Banking's GenAI evolution: Beyond the hype, building the future
In the first episode of a three-part video podcast series sponsored by HCLTech, Sudip Lahiri, Executive Vice President & Head of Financial Services for Europe & UKI at HCLTech explores how financial institutions can navigate the transformative potential of Generative AI while building lasting foundations for innovation.

Beyond compliance: Building unshakeable operational resilience in financial services
In today's rapidly evolving financial landscape, operational resilience has become a critical focus for institutions worldwide. As regulatory requirements grow more complex and cyber threats, particularly ransomware, become increasingly sophisticated, financial services providers must adapt and strengthen their defences. The intersection of compliance, technology, and security presents both challenges and opportunities.

Unleashing generative AI: A force multiplier for financial crime teams
This FStech webinar, sponsored by NICE Actimize sees industry experts examine the revolutionary impact of generative AI on financial crime operations, and provides actionable insights to enhance your compliance strategies.